The Caps suffered a 0-3 home loss to Sanderson on Monday night despite controlling possession for much of the game.
Broughton had several scoring opportunities, but shots were either just wide or at the Sanderson keeper. Sanderson scored two of its goals on set pieces, one off of a free kick toward the end of the first half and another off a long throw-in midway through the second half.
The Caps will try to get back to their recent winning ways when they play at Wakefield on Wednesday.
Earlier, the junior varsity team settled for a 0-0 tie with Sanderson in a game in which both teams had multiple scoring opportunities.